SENG 310 Project Phase 1
- Comments
Please direct any questions to Louis (yul@uvic.ca)
Group 1_01
- You list restaurants as a
stakeholder, so
shouldn't you have a profile to represent that?
- For usability goals, the
system should
also be able to allow easy repair, that is, if the system is down
it should be backed up quickly,
also some
fault tolerant methods should be implemented.
- Can the system be allowed to
reserve
seats for a restaurant online? that would be a nice feature wouldn't it?
(I
didn't take mark off of that, just a suggestion)
- listing a existing way how
customer
finding restaurant and do a comparison would be helpful
- You guys should elaborate on
how you
research to your conclusion of user requirement or user experience
goal. Like
some reasoning, explanation, or some simple interview ect.
- Everyone's getting the same
mark in this
one, if you guys have complaints on whom did more work, let me know
Group 1_02
- very nice intro
- the resturant customer
section, you
separated into tourist and international student, and researchers. I'm
not
sure if that is a complete
classfication of
people whom use the website. What about people whom just decided to
eat out and are not tourist or
international
students.
- you listed waittress as one
of your
profiles, so shouldn't your stakeholder include waittress? But, I don't
think
waittresses should be one of
the
stakeholder, so you shouldn't have a waittress user profile
- shouldn't your user profile
include a
administrator since you made a point that the system should be easy to
maintain?
- The interview you guys did
are excelent
- If the system is designed
partly for
international student, or tourist, shouldn't easy to use or a a clean
and simple
interface be important and part of the user experience goal?
- you guys did some really good
research,
however, putting it together, some points are forgotten, good job
nontheless
Group 1_03
- the intro didn't describe the
system
enough, only provided a short paragraph
- stakeholder, potential
costumers could be
broken down
- Include a system
administrator in your
user profile, since you mentioned it in stakeholder
- There should be more user
experience
goals.
- user requirement, secnario
and so on are
pretty good
Group 1_04
- love the intro
- end user in stakeholder
should be broken
down, at lease show me what different type of users are there
- Again, maybe have a system
administrator
as user profile
- Scenario should be in steps,
it's a bit
messy describing what user did in a chunk
- wait! where is your user
experience and
usability goals, and justifications
Group 1_05
- your interface is a bit
strange
- intro too simple
- usability goals and user
experience goals
are not listed, they are things like "effectiveness" or
"efficientcy"
please see the textbook, also you have to justify why you need
those
goals
- stakeholder are not the same
as names in
user profile, they are things like "customers", or
"administrators"
- in keystakeholder, you
describe a list of
people invovled, but what is "user and stakeholder" suppose to be
- please cleanup your
interface, I'm
getting confused, especially in key stakeholder and stakeholder
- HTA and scenario are too
simple
Group 2_01
- brief intro
- user profile need to
represent all sort
of users, not just students. Teacher maybe? administrtive people
- Please separate the
requirement into user
experience and usability. Also, some user requirement goals would be
nice
- user scenario should be in
steps, and be
more detail
- I do like your HTA
- mainly the mark are taken off
because of
the usability and user experience goals section, but overall some of
the
aspects
needs more reasoning and explanation
Group 2_02
- good intro
- stakeholder list should be
more than
that, also there should be some more explanation with each stakeholder.
- User profile is too limited,
what about a
professor, administrtor.
- where is your usability and
user
experience goals?
- main marks are being deducted
for lack of
usability and user experience goals, and justification
Group 2_03
- nice intro
- there's only two user
profile? Joey and
Joe, and they're similar
- same goes for the user
scenario and HTA
- wait, user requirement don't
need to be
separated into Joey and Joe's
- I can not view the user
requirement
section at all!! and where are your usability and user experience goal
- HTA are completely
unviewable, the
picture can't be shown
- website are entirely too
simple and most
of the things can't be viewed.
Group 2_04
- simple intro
- stakeholders should be better
explained,
and there are more than 2
- why is your main goal after
your key
stakeholder
- simple user profile
- where is your usability goal
and user
expenerience goal
- scenarios are targeted
towards your user
profile, individual users
- so should your HTA
- main the website is lacking
explanation
and try to sum up all the requirements in one or two sentences.
Group 2_05
- really simple webpage
- user profile are done wrong,
it's suppose
to be "Jack, a student" and so on so on, see the webpage for
instruction
- therefore, user scenarios and
HTA are
done (slightly) wrong